My Relationship with Music

I use music as a language. Both as an artist and teacher, I always want to show how music can be used for more than entertainment, or as a vehicle for lyrics in a song, or as atmosphere in the background of a film. Music, all on its own, is something that happens very much in the foreground for me. Its shapes and patterns unfold with a kind of logic, exploring and expressing inner experience. Music tells stories in its own right. It does not need words or pictures. Rhythm and tonality can communicate deep inner feelings or meanings directly, unfolding like a conversation, taking us on a journey.

Of course, it can have so many functions but I can’t help feeling that human beings experience music in this way throughout history and across cultures as its central function. And when we experience music as a language that we can use fluently, it becomes more than the ritual, performance or product that it creates. It becomes our companion. It can be an incredibly powerful way to make sense of life, as it expresses deep, complex or ineffable movements of inner consciousness that words can touch only imperfectly.

For as long as I can remember, that is what music has been to me. And as such, it is a wonderful source of genuine solace, catharsis and joy.

The Piano – Childhood Refuge

I grew up in a home that was emotionally chaotic, and also very strict—I was not encouraged to be expressive at all, and my love of singing was squashed into silence. So, as a child, I always longed for safety, structure and reassurance as well as a feeling of wonder and expressive freedom—a magical place to escape into where imagination could roam. The piano seemed to offer all this.

Long before I understood anything about music theory, I was fascinated by the keyboard itself. The repeating pattern of black and white keys felt deeply reassuring. I loved its symmetry—the mirrors within its layout on all the Ds and G sharps. I found such a sense of ground and safety in the fact that everything belonged somewhere and that it stayed there. So the keyboard felt solid and trustworthy yet also had a certain magic about it, even before it made a sound.

I would sit at the piano and play very simple things that were full of storytelling magic. There was nothing sophisticated about this, it happened more through intention than design. But children so often bring a kind of innocent seriousness to simple activities. I could play just a few notes and feel as though entire worlds were opening up. The sounds felt so extraordinary and mystical to me.

My grandmother encouraged my explorations and would sometimes sit next to me and we would go on musical adventures together. She never seemed particularly concerned with outcomes or achievements. She simply encouraged my curiosity and allowed my flights of fantasy to emerge. So I discovered resonant tones and repeating patterns. Most of all, with the help of simple poetic rhythmic feeling, I created musical stories.

I didn't think of it as practising or striving for anything. I was just playing.

 

The Threat

My parents recognised my musical ability and arranged piano lessons. My first teacher was wonderful. She introduced me to some simple Kodály-inspired activities and gently encouraged my musical development. There was structure, but no pressure. Music still remained a place of discovery and magic.

That changed when I was nine years old. Concerned that I wasn't progressing in the "proper" way, my parents sent me to a much stricter teacher. He taught a highly pressurised version of the conventional way with technique, scales, exercises, theory and highly controlled approaches to interpretation.

I immediately disliked the lessons. I didn’t want to, as I was intensely curious. But what troubled me was the feeling that my own relationship with music was being squeezed out of existence. Everything that felt most alive about the piano seemed to disappear inside the lessons. I had to obey the metronome, execute drills, and his insistence on doing things in highly prescribed ways with a constant focus on correctness felt cramped.

After every lesson, back at home, I would have to take some time to sit at the piano and quietly reclaim my own way of making music. And because I was so frightened of losing this precious place I had found, I began my own inquiry. I started paying very close attention to what I was actually doing. I needed to understand consciously what was going on in order to preserve the thing I loved to do more than anything.

A World of Patterns

I had no ambitions in the usual sense of the word. I wasn't trying to invent a musical system or explain the inner workings of musical language. I was just trying to protect something infinitely precious to me.

What I discovered delighted me so much. I began noticing patterns everywhere.

Instructions for living a life:
Pay attention.
Be astonished.
Tell about it.
 — Mary Oliver

I sensed something of the same symmetry that I had seen in the keys also happening in the structure of the poetic groove. The more I paid attention to this symmetry, the more it held the musical story and caused it to unfold with sense.

I disliked counting. Numbers felt cumbersome to me and made my mind feel static or awkward. Yet rhythm felt natural and flowing. I could sense groups of two or three beats nested inside larger groups of two or three. Those larger groups themselves combine into even larger structures. Groups of four also needed no counting as long as they were made from two groups of two. These rhythmic cells felt not metronomic at all but flexible and stable. Most of all they were intelligible and meaningful, like words.

And these patterns nested within patterns held a kaleidoscopic thrill for me. I was mesmerised. No need for arithmetic, nothing to calculate. I knew where I was in the unfolding structure because I could feel it.

I loved the sensation of knowing exactly where I was in a structure that held me safe as it flowed effortlessly, rising and falling, creating a poetic or conversational feeling through a quality of "this-ness" followed by "that-ness". The musical story made sense because of this unfolding structure.

It felt like it was speaking and I would whisper nonsense speech to help me feel connected to its articulate sense. Later I developed mantras for teaching students to connect their fingers to the natural rhythmic storytelling.

And of course, the keyboard presented itself as repeating groups of two black keys and three black keys. Around them sat corresponding groups of three and four white keys. Everywhere I looked there were relationships, patterns, symmetries and mirrors.

What I now call the Rhythmic Matrix and the Keyboard Map emerged from these observations of a child. It felt like the landscape of music was gradually revealing itself to me. It was just there welcoming me. I had already intuited something about it as a very small child. It felt natural and required no construction or explaining. I was discovering it.

The Musical Landscape and its Contents

Once I started seeing these underlying rhythmic and tonal structures, I couldn't stop exploring the sounds that lived inside them. These sounds felt like musical vocabulary. I discovered twelve rhythm cells. Twelve major and twelve minor harmonic blocks, which are a little like chords but configured through the whole keyboard with its symmetry and structure defining them as recognisable structures.

I found the diatonic blocks – which are a little like scales – and the families of six harmonic blocks that they contain. I had been playing with the delightfully symmetric whole-tone blocks for years. I had intuitively loved them as a child because they sounded like space itself. Later I discovered the diminished blocks and finally the pentatonic blocks.

All kinds of tonal colours appeared to me as I pursued them with enormous enthusiasm because I loved the feeling of finding them and discovering what they could “say”. Rhythms too became increasingly complex as I played with the twelve rhythm cells in various matrix structures. It was pure joy making musical shapes, “saying” them with intention, almost like words, that flowed together in the matrix to make perfect sense.

No one had assigned the task. No examination board required it. No teacher suggested it. I was driven by simple curiosity and a delight in exploring the musical landscape. Eventually when I realised that there were no more tonal blocks or rhythm cells to be found, I remember feeling briefly disappointed. Surely there should have been more? But the building blocks were finite whereas what could be done with them was anything but. The possibilities were endless.

Defiance Without Rage

The rather sad truth is that I kept all this secret. I had to protect this thing that was mine. Although it gave me a kind of sovereignty, I also feared losing it. If my mother caught me improvising, or "piddling about" as she called it, she could become very angry. Sometimes she threatened to sell the piano altogether.

So I learned to hide. I practised what I was expected to practise or at least made it look as if that’s what I was practising. For example, I would learn music for my teacher quickly, by ear, with flexible, stable, storytelling rhythm. But in the lesson I would hide one of my hands so he wouldn’t see the fingers moving to pretend I had learned each staff of the score hands-separately. And I would play with robotic, metronomic manners to pretend that I had practised with the metronome, lifting my fingers high, making a percussive sound. This was what he wanted.

I learned to perform in competitions, although sometimes I would get so nervous and play in my own way. Interestingly and confusingly too, I would still win when this happened. But couldn't help feeling that it might be wrong, that I was cheating. My aim was to imitate the conventions of successful classical performance which often sounded less intelligible or naturally expressive than I would have liked. But I became rather good at copying that sound.

But for me, the real music remained elsewhere. In secret, I explored, improvised. continued expanding my understanding of the musical language. And for a long time I felt guilty and ashamed about it on the outside. But on the inside, I felt a sense of mischievous delight at my defiance.

I learned to enjoy the naughty feeling of finding music so natural and enjoyable. I coined a phrase for this feeling: "defiance without rage". I still think of this as a powerful technique or mental skill. It’s a way of quietly remaining staunchly faithful to my own musical instincts without having to feel bitter or rebellious.

To be yourself in a world that is constantly trying to make you something else is the greatest accomplishment.
 — Ralph Waldo Emerson

It meant that I held onto a kind of sovereignty. That act of inward loyalty became extraordinarily important. It created the space for me to develop my musical fluency.

After a few years something remarkable happened. Every piece of music I encountered occupied my familiar landscape. All music began to feel like a story I could tell easily using the language I understood. Even very complex improvisation began to feel entirely natural. I could play things by ear that had previously felt out of reach, complex jazzy tonality was no longer obscure. Sight-reading and writing down music I heard or imagined became natural as the speed of my musical processing accelerated dramatically.

Aged eleven I played my first concerto in public. People often assumed these abilities must be the result of unusual talent, that I was a child prodigy or that I was a strange obsessive super-geek immersed in theoretical and technical study. My mother would amplify these myths even though I’m sure she sensed that they were not true.

My own experience was nothing of the sort but I simply continued quietly immersed in my approach. I wasn't trying to become impressive, exceptional or to win. The only thing that motivated me still was curiosity, exploring a language I loved.

The only choice we have as we mature is how we inhabit our vulnerability.
— David Whyte

My Outlook on Music Today

When I found out that many musicians from the past possessed similar forms of fluency, this caused me to challenge the idea that I was doing something that had to be kept secret, something that was cheating in some way. In the past composing, improvising, playing by ear and performing were seen as parts of the same musical skill set.

This gave me enormous reassurance to understand that what I had discovered was something I could share. There are many ways of approaching music-making. Mine is just one and I would never claim that it is inherently better. Nor do I claim that the model I use and teach is a grand unified theory of music. But I think it has a certain naturalness of expression that perhaps current norms of music education don’t foster. And that it is empowering to be able to “speak” music with ease, intention and authenticity in the moment.

I love music to tell stories that are relatable. I have always found myself drawn to music that feels coherent and intelligibly meaningful. I love the feeling that every phrase belongs where it is and leads naturally to the next to move the musical argument forwards. When listening to all genres and styles of music, including classical or jazz, I always listen for a story that makes perfect sense.

And I realise that many people, would-be musicians and actual practising musicians have a belief that fluent improvisation, composition, playing by ear and “speaking” music naturally belong only to a gifted few. I truly believe that my experience suggests otherwise. The model I use is surprisingly simple. In fact, its simplicity can sometimes be difficult for people to accept. We often assume that profound things must be complicated. I honestly think that anyone who loves music, who is touched by its message, has the innate ability to learn to become fluent in it. Passion is the fuel that generates the necessary focus and immersion.

Children rarely make that mistake. They simply explore what fascinates them. That is how I learned and so now it is how I teach adults—to rediscover that deep connection to music that already exists in them as the basis for playful, exploratory practice.

How and Why I Teach

I teach these principles to people of different ages, backgrounds and instruments. Rhythm comes first and its principles are universal for all instruments, of course. In many ways, the keyboard and the voice feel especially powerful disciplines for developing tonal fluency. I reclaimed and freed my singing voice fully by applying principles of rhythm and tonality and have come to realise that the voice feels like the perfect complement to the keyboard musical fluency training. I encourage students of all instruments to discover how vocal and keyboard fluency can open up a profound understanding of tonality.

Again and again I have watched students discover a freedom they assumed was unavailable to them. Generally, this is not so much because they acquired something new that feels dazzling and impressive to them but more often because they rediscovered something old and familiar within a way of doing it that is simply expressive and honest. Because we possess a natural inner sense of rhythm and tonal relationship and also an impulse to express ourselves using these senses.

Studying musical fluency can be quick as it was for me on the piano; or it can be a long complex journey like my singing journey was. People have psychological and emotional baggage around music. It can feel intimidating to let go and be expressive in the almost uncivilised way that is necessary. Focus can also be challenging. We live in a world of distraction, quick fixes and at times deception and illusion. This practice requires the kind of honesty and freedom from the egoic drives towards accomplishment or impressive results that just get in the way.

But when people start to focus and let go to express themselves with simple honesty, it is pure magic. Watching that happen never gets old.

The only journey is the one within.
 — Rainer Maria Rilke

I love how the model can become a compact survival kit so that the expedition can go to perilous places. You wouldn’t jump off the edge without a parachute or surf massive waves without a surfboard. But I also love how it can feel like a set of simple gardening tools. With a model of how music works, it becomes possible to defy the negative thoughts—gremlins in our heads that can frighten and limit us if we let them.

I love the patterns and structures that make music a language we can speak with clarity and intention. But as a teacher, I get incredibly excited when I hear people use that language to tell their own stories, to discover things about their inner worlds, and find solace, catharsis and joy for themselves.

We Are the Music

The greatest gift musical fluency has given me is not technical at all, but personal. The music remains mine—not in the sense of ownership so much as relationship. It has continued to be my companion throughout my life. It feels like a safe place I can inhabit. It provides the permission to express myself with unfiltered honesty.

Music is a place where questions can be explored and the answers or stories that appear don't need to be explained or analysed. This means that music can be extremely personal. But paradoxically it also becomes universal. The more honestly we speak, the more others recognise themselves in what they hear.

Being fluent in the language of music means that I love it today for the same reason I loved it as a child. One reason is because it has lucid, beautiful, mesmerising patterns that are reassuringly unchanging and impart meanings that we all understand. The other reason is that tells the most magical stories. Its sounds touch me deeply and alter my consciousness in ways that are so positive. Even the most difficult, dark feelings become radiant. And after a lifetime exploring its landscape, I feel the same invitation now as I did as a child sitting at the piano: come and discover some musical magic!