Which is the best piano in Pianoteq?

In our rather competitive culture, I’ve noticed how pianos often get compared to each other, with a view to deciding which one comes out top. People even like to argue about which one is best rather than simply acknowledging that a certain instrument may just be their personal favourite. Perhaps the human mind is geared this way innately, to look for our favourite things and defend them against other people’s. But it might be a rather impoverished way of thinking, that fails to celebrate diversity.

It’s all about what you get used to

As a child, we had a lovely old Grotrian grand piano, with a big, bright tone, a light action and a slightly disconcerting if exciting tendency to sway when you started playing big chords. I became so attached to this very unique instrument. It became my standard and other pianos felt odd in comparison. They had dull, introverted tones with heavy actions that needed too much force to extract brilliance. But of course, that was not true except in comparison to my personal “normal” of the Grotrian piano which I played on every day.

My favourite piano model in Pianoteq

I can’t deny that I have most fun playing the New York Steinway in Pianoteq. So I could say that it’s my favourite. This may well be because of underlying condition: firstly, the model D Steinway is an industry standard that you will hear on many, if not most classical piano recordings; secondly, at my music college, we had lots of Steinway pianos that I practised on all the time, so they became my normal.

Letting the piano control me a little

One of the things I developed as a gigging classical pianist, was the ability to adapt to different pianos. My way of doing this was to improvise on the instrument freely to discover its special qualities. This way, I would stop fighting with it, often in a futile attempt to make it “speak” like a Steinway and would allow it to speak to me. So it became a two-way conversation. And this interaction would generate magic, as I adjusted my playing to naturally bring out particular sonorities, feelings, colours and moods. I let myself fall in love with the piano with all its idiosyncrasies, quirks, flaws and of course strengths.

Bringing out the qualities of each piano and each preset in Pianoteq

I’ve been reflecting on this lately and considering how I could challenge my tendency to always choose the Model D Steinway for my practice. I have decided to improvise and practise on different instruments to bring out their various unique musical essences which will inform my playing and help to keep me inspired. I will release videos exploring individual pianos and presets and the kind of music they bring out of me as I improvise using them. I intend also to share some of the fruits of this process by creating packs of midi stems that people can purchase and download. I may even start developing some presets of my own. The possibilities are intriguing…

Using Pianoteq’s YC5 and Native Instrument’s Alicia’s Keys I demonstrate how there are pros and cons to physically modelled pianos and sampled pianos, depending on how you choose to use them.

Exploring Werkmeister III temperament (tuning) on the bright, lively tones of the J. Schantz (1790) fortepiano in Pianoteq.